Cigar Reviews!

"Cigar reviews offer enthusiasts a flavorful journey through the world of fine tobacco, where each puff unveils a tapestry of nuanced aromas, rich flavors, and expert craftsmanship. Delving beyond mere smoke, these reviews meticulously dissect the anatomy of cigars, exploring their origins, blends, construction, and aging processes.

Each review is a sensory exploration, capturing the essence of the cigar experience through vivid descriptions of its appearance, aroma, draw, and burn. From the silky touch of the wrapper to the satisfying weight of the ash, every detail is savored and critiqued with precision.

But it's the flavor profile that truly takes center stage, as reviewers decode a symphony of tastes ranging from earthy notes of leather and cedar to hints of spice, chocolate, and espresso. With a discerning palate, they assess the complexity, balance, and evolution of flavors throughout the smoke, guiding readers on a gustatory adventure.

Beyond the individual characteristics, cigar reviews also delve into the broader context of the cigar industry, discussing trends, brands, and emerging blends. Whether exploring classic Cuban classics or innovative boutique creations, these reviews serve as a compass for aficionados navigating the vast seas of cigar culture.

In essence, cigar reviews are more than just critiques; they're a celebration of craftsmanship, tradition, and the timeless pleasure of savoring a fine cigar."
Based on 10344 reviews
93%
(9595)
6%
(626)
0%
(18)
0%
(3)
0%
(5)
Simply Amazing

This cigar checks all of the boxes. Construction, draw, burn and flavor make this cigar a MUST TRY!

Great stick

Smoked smooth and had great flavor

Feel like a high plains drifter.

Thick wrappers with delicious fill and a smooth smoke for when you dont have time for a long session. These are my new best friend when I take the dog out for a quick break. No added flavors or sugar to ruin the experience. Buy 'em and hand them out to your friends. Don't have friends? Give one to a stranger and Bam! Instant new friend. Stop being so selfish! Onward Christian Soldier.

Very High Quality Cigar

Mellow woody flavor with a hint of sharp, dark tobacco. The wrapping was among the best I've seen. It burned slowly and evenly. This is not a basic cigar, you are smoking a top notch with the Heidelberg Maduro. Everything you could want in a Maduro is found in this piece. If you want a premium experience then this is the place to look.

Good stuff!

Have really enjoyed the cigars! I’m a novice but quality seems great and it was shipped quickly. Only feedback is that the description led me to believe it would include some information on the cigars and tips for how to enjoy them but it didn’t.

I’ve only had the London Maduro so far but it’s fantastic!

Perfect am cigar

Paired nicely with my morning coffee on the deck. I really enjoyed the amount of smoke and the creaminess.

J
Gordo 6 x 60 Maduro Sandwich Daily Smokes (25) Pack
John L Shepherd
Maduro Sandwich

Unfortunately these cigars were terrible! I would give zero stars if I could. They were all completely unsmokeable. The construction was terrible. The wrappers came off before lighting. They virtually fell apart just cutting the cap. Worst cigars I've ever seen!

M
Gordo 6 x 60 Maduro Sandwich Daily Smokes (25) Pack
Michael
Good Price, Low Quality

I bought it for the good price, and because I've never had a bad cigar from 1689 cigars. But these cigars do not have much taste to me. More than that, however, is the poor construction. The cap breaks off easily, and I end up with cigar pieces in my mouth. I've loved every cigar I've had from 1689, but these are disappointing.

Excellent daily smoker

Can’t beat them for the price. ~$2.50/stick with taxes and shipping is cheaper than I was paying for some nice cigarillos but now I get to enjoy a full size cigar after lunch.

The preaching badger

Great burn and great taste. Lasted about 45 minutes.

I do want to get the lighter and cutter from 1689 if possible.

Very good cigar

Very good Cigars. I bought these for my daily use.

Great stick.

Excellent flavor throughout, construction was really nice from light up to the nub, definitely be buying more and interested in your connecticut blend.

A great give away

These sticks are excellent for giving away and for a brief smoke. Is it my favorite Maduro? Well, no, I’d prefer a larger gauge, but if you’re learning about cigars, what wrappers, fillers, and gauge you prefer, these are an excellent way to get into the world. They don’t always burn evenly, and sometimes wrapping is inconsistent, but again, for what it is, it’s well worth the money. If you give one to someone and they break it on the golf course, oh well, if you have a few friends over to chew fat, they’re a welcome addition to the convo.

Torpedo 6 1/8 x 52 Habano Sandwich Daily Smokes (25) Pack?

Torpedo 6 1/8 x 52 Habano Sandwich Daily Smokes (25) Pack?

Great construction
Great mild cigar with Woodsy Leathery notes

Everyday smoke for sure, will purchase again

Good flavor, burn good some have a tendency to canoe, construction fair, wrapper thin has a tendency to tear If not careful, 10-15 % came with wrapper all ready damaged in the package, would rate it 85% overall, taste and nuances will have me purchase again when offered on sale.

Q
Gordo 6 x 60 Connecticut Sandwich Daily Smokes (25) Pack
Q Mercer
Fantastic daily smoke.

I have really enjoyed the cigars right off the bat. I am a sad, especially considering the price, but they’re great and the price just makes them better. These are gonna last me a while, but I will definitely be ordering this pack again. Highly recommend.

R
Gordo 6 x 60 Maduro Sandwich Daily Smokes (25) Pack
Rev. Nick

Gordo 6 x 60 Maduro Sandwich Daily Smokes (25) Pack

Great flavor and value

I ordered a 25-count for an upcoming event, and had a few friends sample a handful ahead of time.

We all enjoyed the flavor, and found that it paired well with Eagle Rare. Fantastic flavor for the price point. All of ours were well rolled and burned evenly without splits or canoes.

Mystery box

The mystery box was fun. There were a selection of cigars and a lighter/v cutter in the box along with the stickers. Excellent cigars

R
Robusto 5 × 50 Maduro
Richard Powell
Great stick

The brotherhood collection maduro is an excellent stick. Highly satisfied with 1689!

Excellent quality

I enjoy the Corona (madero) 10 pack - great smoke and love supporting not just small business, but a based Christian business!

The Confession Line Sample Pack.

7 for $77 Reformed/1689 Cigars all 7 Blends